Though the reading “War on Women” wasn’t a very good one an affirmation made within the article still resonates within me daily. “Women’s rights are not necessarily human rights.” To be clear I will speak on a specific issue, let’s say abortion. When questioned about my feelings toward abortion I always brushed it off by saying, “People are going to do what they want and justify it by any means they find convenient, or they will rely on someone else to tell them what to do.” I realized that this answer was no longer valid. This was not because it was untrue, but because it doesn’t answer the question. This is a question of Ethics, something I never quite understood. It is not what people do and do not do, but what they ought and ought not do. It is a question of responsibility.
The argument most often justifying abortion in a moral perspective is, “It’s my body and I can do what I want with it.” Yea, it is my body and I can turn it into a weapon, become a misanthrope and commit mass genocide, ’cause it’s my mind, my body and I can do what I want. Right, so this is not O.K. with some people, I’m sure. This, in the same way, is not O.K. with a women being irresponsible, having a child who she cannot provide for, and leaving for him to fend for himself most likely committing violent acts out of desperation. So, would it therefore be okay to have an abortion and letting your ends justify your means bringing us to the next ethical issue.
The sanctity of human life and human life is intrinsically good, therefore we should not kill; and we should not kill because I certainty don’t want anybody to kill me… so as long as I can’t identify with it (say a fetus) I can kill it… principle. This is a silly argument. If I can somehow prove that it isn’t alive I can’t kill it. This leads to the when is the fetus alive argument, which is a trivial tangent argument that in my belief is a way of avoiding the issue. This is because it isn’t about killing. When you scratch a mosquito bite you’re killing cells, in the process of ejaculation you’re killing millions of cells and when you walk down the street and kill ants and pollute you’re killing. You kill all the time so don’t pretend that’s the issue. The real issue here is, “If the means justify the ends is it okay and what is the criteria if so.” I think if we focused on that rather than being specific, we could resolve many human rights issues. This is the ethical question.
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.